The credit report as instrument of extralegal justice

Author

Dominique Gervais; Geneviève Charlet

Organization

Option consommateurs

Published

2013

Summary

A creditor who claims that a consumer owes him sum of money may cause a negative entry in the latter’s credit report. In doing so, the creditor exercises his power to punish the consumer without having to prove the merits of his claim before a court of law. This raises ethical issues since the creditor controls the information released, it is as if he were at the same time judge and plaintiff.

Entering a negative entry in a credit report reverses the burden of proof. Even though it is the creditor who is claiming a right - the right to claim his due - if the entry is false, inaccurate, incomplete or disputed (which is common), it is up to the consumer to prove that it is so. To avoid the trouble caused by a negative entry on a credit report, the consumer can of course decide to pay the sum demanded under protest and then sue the creditor. But there again, the burden of proof rests with the consumer.

Admittedly, protection of privacy laws impose certain rules and guidelines regarding the accuracy of the information contained in credit reports and give consumers the right to correct information and add explanatory notes to their files. But how effective are the measures in place? Can an explanatory note really offset the negative perception created by a negative entry? Are such notes taken into in account in calculating the credit rating?

In this research, Option consommateurs (OC) wanted to examine the effectiveness of the existing rules and assess whether they adequately protect the consumer.

This document is available in the following language(s):

Third-Party Information Liability Disclaimer

Some of the information on this Web page has been provided by external sources. The Government of Canada is not responsible for the accuracy, reliability or currency of the information supplied by external sources. Users wishing to rely upon this information should consult directly with the source of the information. Content provided by external sources is not subject to official languages, privacy and accessibility requirements.

English and French

• French (PDF document)

OCA Funded Research
This research received funding support through the Office of Consumer Affairs' Contributions Program.

Contact information

Source: Consumer Policy Research Database