Appendix 2 (continued)
Selected SIBS tables (continued)
| Symbol | Meaning | Coefficient of variationFootnote t | Standard error (SE) |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | Very reliable | ≤ 5 % | ≤ 2.5 |
| B | Reliable | > 5 % and ≤ 15 % | > 2.5 and ≤7.5 |
| E | Use with caution | > 15 % and ≤ 30 % | > 7.5 and ≤15 |
| F | Too unreliable to be published | > 30 % | > 15 |
| X | Suppressed to meet the confidentiality requirements of the Statistics Act | ||
| ... | Not applicable | ||
| By industry | Changed the quality of the product | Adopted a new technology or process | Changed marketing expenditures | Introduced a new product | Speeded up the introduction of a new product | Changed the price of the product | Other action | Took no action | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | |
| All surveyed industries | 37.7 | E | 17.6 | B | 33.3 | B | 40.1 | B | 18.1 | B | 69.5 | B | 19 | E | 20.5 | B |
| Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | ||||||||
| Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction | 26.2 | E | 22.7 | B | 22.8 | B | 28.5 | E | 11.4 | B | 40.2 | E | 2.8 | A | 33.3 | E |
| Utilities | 9.9 | B | 13.5 | B | 24.7 | B | 23.5 | E | 6.8 | B | 36.5 | E | 2.9 | A | 42.6 | E |
| Construction | 1.7 | B | 1.7 | B | 1.7 | B | 0 | A | 0 | A | F | 0 | A | F | ||
| Manufacturing | 35.7 | A | 39.2 | A | 38.6 | A | 37.4 | A | 28.6 | A | 64.8 | A | 9.9 | A | 15.5 | A |
| Food | 30.4 | B | 33 | B | 50.6 | B | 51.6 | B | 28.8 | B | 67.3 | B | 4.2 | A | 13.6 | B |
| Beverage and tobacco product | 26.1 | E | 13.9 | B | 70.5 | E | 64.7 | E | 35.9 | E | 31.1 | E | 23 | E | 22.1 | E |
| Textile mills | 54.1 | E | 22.6 | B | 38.5 | E | 46.7 | E | 38.9 | E | 46.7 | E | 23.3 | B | 22.9 | B |
| Textile product mills | 14.8 | E | 0 | A | 50.3 | E | 20.1 | E | 0 | A | 65.1 | E | 4.8 | B | 0 | A |
| Clothing | 42.6 | E | 21.5 | E | 20.4 | E | 47.8 | E | 34.8 | E | 55 | E | 12.1 | B | 24.2 | E |
| Leather and allied product | 55.6 | B | 56 | B | 44.4 | B | 55.6 | B | 55.6 | B | 66.8 | B | 0 | A | 10.8 | B |
| Wood product | 52.5 | E | 39.3 | E | 39 | E | 16.7 | B | 22 | B | 83.4 | B | 9.7 | B | 7.4 | B |
| Paper | 24.3 | B | 28.3 | E | 55.2 | E | 21.5 | B | 15.1 | B | 74.9 | E | 4.3 | B | 15.9 | B |
| Printing and related support activities | 40 | E | 46.5 | E | 33.1 | E | 34.4 | E | 25.1 | E | 60.9 | E | 0.7 | A | 29.8 | E |
| Petroleum and coal product | 16.6 | E | 33.8 | E | 0 | A | 33.1 | E | 16.6 | E | 50.3 | E | 0 | A | 33.1 | E |
| Chemical manufacturing except pharmaceutical | 33.4 | B | 33.4 | B | 25.2 | B | 34.2 | B | 23.4 | B | 41.7 | B | 4.9 | B | 16.4 | B |
| Pharmaceutical | 32.6 | B | 48.5 | B | 37.7 | B | 51.8 | E | 44.9 | B | 58.3 | E | 0 | A | 18.9 | B |
| Plastics and rubber products | 44.5 | E | 52.1 | E | 40.1 | E | 55.8 | E | 37.3 | E | 66.8 | E | 25.5 | B | 16.4 | B |
| Motor vehicle plastic parts | 35.9 | E | 74.3 | E | 51.3 | E | 51.3 | E | 51.3 | E | 61.5 | E | 51.3 | E | 25.7 | E |
| Non-metallic mineral product | 30.1 | E | 34.2 | E | 44.8 | E | 35.2 | E | 23.1 | B | 44.7 | E | 13.6 | B | 17.8 | B |
| Primary metal | 32.6 | B | 39.8 | B | 22.9 | B | 29.2 | B | 29.1 | B | 63 | B | 2.9 | A | 19.3 | B |
| Fabricated metal product | 21 | B | 36.3 | B | 30.5 | B | 17.6 | B | 12.4 | B | 80.2 | B | 4.6 | A | 15.2 | B |
| Machinery | 38 | B | 38.3 | B | 33.4 | B | 27.3 | B | 22 | B | 49.9 | B | 27.9 | B | 26.1 | B |
| Computer and electronic product | 48 | B | 47.1 | B | 43 | B | 71.4 | B | 57.2 | B | 53 | B | 2.7 | A | 12.7 | B |
| Electrical equipment, appliance and component | 47.3 | B | 50.4 | B | 50.3 | B | 47.3 | B | 36.1 | B | 73.9 | B | 13.8 | B | 5.4 | A |
| Transportation equipment | 53 | B | 58.7 | B | 46.3 | B | 35.3 | B | 35.8 | B | 61.8 | B | 6.5 | B | 6.1 | A |
| Motor vehicle | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | ||||||||
| Motor vehicle body and trailer | 59.7 | E | 58.6 | E | 65.5 | E | 29 | B | 29 | B | 71.9 | B | 5.5 | B | 2 | A |
| Motor vehicle parts | 46.1 | E | 57.7 | E | 28.1 | E | 36.5 | E | 42.9 | E | 57.8 | E | 11.5 | B | 5.1 | A |
| Aerospace product and parts | 54.9 | B | 66.1 | B | 53.5 | B | 28.3 | B | 17.8 | B | 44.5 | B | 0 | A | 5.3 | B |
| Furniture and related product | 20.6 | B | 24.3 | E | 32.6 | E | 38.6 | E | 39 | E | 77.1 | E | 5 | B | 8.1 | B |
| Miscellaneous | 36.1 | E | 62.4 | E | 54.4 | E | 70.6 | E | 55 | E | 56.9 | E | 0 | A | 3.9 | B |
| All surveyed industries except manufacturing | 38.2 | E | 13 | B | 32.2 | E | 40.7 | E | 15.8 | E | 70.5 | B | 21 | E | 21.6 | B |
| Wholesale Trade | F | 12.5 | E | F | 12.5 | E | 12.5 | E | F | 0 | A | F | ||||
| Retail Trade | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | ||||||||
| Transportation and warehousing | 44 | E | 20.1 | B | 32.1 | E | 19.6 | B | 16 | B | 71.8 | B | 11.8 | B | 17.4 | B |
| Information and cultural industries | 49.9 | E | 54.3 | E | 44.2 | B | 50.6 | E | 43.9 | E | 46.4 | E | 7.6 | B | 21.5 | B |
| Finance and insurance | 27.8 | B | 18.9 | B | 37 | E | 18.6 | B | 15.9 | B | 42.1 | E | 2.8 | B | 32.3 | B |
| Real estate and rental and leasing | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | |||||||||
| Professional, scientific, and technical services except scientific research and development services br> Scientific research and development services | 41.7 | E | 42.3 | E | 45.8 | E | 44.5 | E | 20.9 | B | 46.2 | E | 4.4 | A | 25.1 | E |
| Management of companies and enterprises | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | ||||||||
| Administrative and support, waste management and remediation services | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | ||||||||
| By firm size | Changed the quality of the product | Adopted a new technology or process | Changed marketing expenditures | Introduced a new product | Speeded up the introduction of a new product | Changed the price of the product | Other action | Took no action | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | ||
| All industries | Large Enterprises | F | F | F | F | 13.1 | E | F | F | F | |||||||
| Medium Enterprises | F | F | F | F | 20.0 | E | F | 6.5 | B | F | |||||||
| Small Enterprises | 36.3 | E | 14.3 | B | 34.2 | E | 40.0 | E | 18.3 | E | 71.4 | B | 20.7 | E | 20.3 | B | |
| Manufacturing | Large Enterprises | 40.6 | A | 41.8 | A | 42.1 | A | 48.2 | A | 43.1 | A | 67.6 | A | 10.4 | A | 11.5 | A |
| Medium Enterprises | 42.9 | B | 40.0 | B | 38.7 | B | 39.7 | B | 35.9 | B | 71.3 | B | 11.0 | A | 11.7 | A | |
| Small Enterprises | 34.1 | A | 38.8 | A | 38.4 | A | 36.1 | A | 26.1 | A | 63.5 | A | 9.7 | A | 16.4 | A | |
| All Except Manufacturing | Large Enterprises | F | F | F | F | 5.7 | B | F | F | F | |||||||
| Medium Enterprises | F | F | F | F | 12.5 | E | F | 4.3 | B | F | |||||||
| Small Enterprises | 36.8 | E | 9.5 | A | 33.4 | E | 40.8 | E | 16.7 | E | 73 | B | 22.8 | E | 21 | B | |
| By industry | Product innovation | Process innovation | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goods | Services | Methods of manufacturing or producing | Logistics, delivery or distribution methods | Supporting activities for processes | ||||||
| % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | |
| All surveyed industries | 18.1 | A | 24.5 | B | 17.3 | A | 12.0 | A | 25.5 | B |
| Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting | 0.0 | A | F | F | F | F | ||||
| Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction | 18.1 | B | 18.3 | B | 19.2 | B | 8.0 | B | 19.1 | B |
| Utilities | 11.0 | A | 16.6 | B | 10.3 | A | 14.3 | B | 23.9 | B |
| Construction | 0.0 | A | 17.8 | E | 8.9 | E | 16.3 | E | 46.4 | E |
| Manufacturing | 42.6 | A | 21.7 | A | 49.7 | A | 15.7 | A | 31.4 | A |
| Food | 36.5 | B | 14.4 | A | 45.0 | B | 17.7 | A | 25.8 | B |
| Beverage and tobacco product | 55.9 | B | 21.6 | B | 56.4 | E | 26.0 | B | 32.9 | B |
| Textile mills | 55.3 | B | 25.7 | B | 60.3 | B | 19.0 | B | 32.5 | B |
| Textile product mills | 40.4 | B | 19.3 | B | 44.4 | B | 13.2 | B | 24.2 | B |
| Clothing | 34.7 | B | 16.5 | B | 18.4 | B | 8.1 | B | 11.9 | B |
| Leather and allied product | 61.7 | B | 17.0 | B | 45.2 | B | 22.1 | B | 27.4 | B |
| Wood product | 34.3 | B | 21.7 | B | 51.6 | B | 13.8 | B | 27.0 | B |
| Paper | 33.8 | B | 17.8 | B | 50.7 | B | 15.4 | B | 32.9 | B |
| Printing and related support activities | 29.1 | B | 29.6 | B | 52.1 | B | 18.4 | B | 41.2 | B |
| Petroleum and coal product | 50.1 | B | 11.6 | B | 26.9 | B | 11.6 | B | 23.0 | B |
| Chemical manufacturing except pharmaceutical | 48.4 | B | 24.2 | B | 50.2 | B | 19.3 | B | 34.4 | B |
| Pharmaceutical | 59.0 | B | 25.8 | B | 50.3 | B | 27.1 | B | 41.7 | B |
| Plastics and rubber products | 57.8 | B | 31.7 | B | 58.9 | B | 14.6 | B | 32.3 | B |
| Motor vehicle plastic parts | 61.9 | B | 37.3 | B | 69.0 | B | 20.4 | B | 57.1 | B |
| Non-metallic mineral product | 37.6 | B | 14.8 | B | 46.8 | B | 14.0 | B | 26.8 | B |
| Primary metal | 41.9 | B | 22.5 | B | 56.1 | B | 16.5 | A | 34.1 | B |
| Fabricated metal product | 30.0 | B | 23.4 | B | 50.1 | B | 14.1 | B | 34.4 | B |
| Machinery | 57.1 | B | 24.2 | B | 50.9 | B | 13.6 | B | 36.6 | B |
| Computer and electronic product | 61.8 | B | 28.9 | B | 49.2 | B | 20.8 | B | 29.5 | B |
| Electrical equipment, appliance and component | 56.3 | B | 20.3 | B | 56.0 | B | 16.5 | A | 35.1 | B |
| Transportation equipment | 43.8 | A | 19.3 | A | 53.6 | A | 17.1 | A | 33.2 | A |
| Motor vehicle | 44.4 | B | 22.2 | B | 72.2 | B | 27.8 | B | 50.0 | B |
| Motor vehicle body and trailer | 47.9 | B | 15.1 | B | 41.5 | B | 6.8 | A | 33.4 | B |
| Motor vehicle parts | 39.3 | B | 16.9 | B | 59.9 | B | 19.8 | B | 29.9 | B |
| Aerospace product and parts | 48.4 | B | 32.2 | B | 61.1 | B | 33.2 | B | 47.5 | B |
| Furniture and related product | 37.8 | B | 9.6 | B | 44.0 | B | 10.7 | B | 26.6 | B |
| Miscellaneous | 52.6 | B | 27.5 | B | 57.0 | B | 21.6 | B | 34.0 | B |
| All surveyed industries except manufacturing | 12.6 | A | 25.1 | B | 9.9 | A | 11.1 | B | 24.2 | B |
| Wholesale Trade | 29.9 | E | 21.0 | B | 17.7 | B | 19.8 | B | 24.2 | E |
| Retail Trade | 0.7 | A | F | 0.7 | A | 0.0 | A | 13.9 | E | |
| Transportation and warehousing | 8.7 | A | 29.1 | B | 8.4 | A | 24.0 | B | 25.1 | B |
| Information and cultural industries | 31.4 | B | 46.2 | B | 22.8 | B | 16.2 | B | 22.9 | B |
| Finance and insurance | 17.4 | B | 27.0 | B | 12.0 | B | 9.0 | B | 22.8 | B |
| Real estate and rental and leasing | 1.7 | E | 3.1 | E | 0.0 | A | 27.0 | E | 28.7 | E |
| Professional, scientific, and technical services except scientific research and development services | 20.8 | B | 41.6 | B | 22.5 | B | 11.6 | B | 33.0 | B |
| Scientific research and development services | 41.1 | B | 39.5 | B | 31.2 | B | 10.4 | B | 39 | B |
| Management of companies and enterprises | 0 | A | 0 | A | 0 | A | 0 | A | 0 | A |
| Administrative and support, waste management and remediation services | 38.3 | E | F | 12.1 | E | 8.9 | E | 12.1 | E | |
| By firm size | Product innovation | Process innovation | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goods | Services | Methods of manufacturing or producing | Logistics, delivery or distribution methods | Supporting activities for processes | |||||||
| % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | ||
| All industries | Large Enterprises | 29.3 | E | F | F | 16.0 | E | F | |||
| Medium Enterprises | 24.1 | B | 23.4 | E | 24.3 | E | 14.1 | B | 28.0 | E | |
| Small Enterprises | 16.4 | A | 23.6 | B | 14.8 | A | 11.3 | A | 24.3 | B | |
| Manufacturing | Large Enterprises | 52.2 | A | 21.0 | A | 54.0 | A | 24.5 | A | 38.4 | A |
| Medium Enterprises | 49.6 | A | 20.9 | A | 53.3 | A | 16.6 | A | 32.9 | A | |
| Small Enterprises | 40.3 | A | 21.9 | A | 48.6 | A | 14.5 | A | 30.3 | A | |
| All Except Manufacturing | Large Enterprises | F | F | F | F | F | |||||
| Medium Enterprises | 17.1 | E | 24.1 | E | 16.3 | E | 13.4 | E | 26.6 | E | |
| Small Enterprises | 11.3 A | 24.0 | B | 7.7 | A | 10.7 | B | 23.1 | B | ||
| By industry | Organizational innovation | Marketing innovation | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Business practices for organizing procedures | Methods of organizing work responsibilities procedures | Methods of organizing external relations | Aesthetic design or packaging | Methods or techniques for promotion | Methods for product placement | Methods of pricing | ||||||||
| % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | |
| All surveyed industries | 23.5 | A | 27.4 | B | 15.0 | A | 11.3 | A | 23.9 | B | 14.0 | B | 15.8 | B |
| Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting | F | F | F | F | F | F | F | |||||||
| Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction | 36.7 | B | 38.7 | B | 16.9 | B | 10.1 | B | 14.9 | B | 4.6 | A | 16.7 | B |
| Utilities | 32.3 | B | 44.8 | B | 24.8 | B | 9.9 | B | 17.1 | B | 5.5 | A | 6.3 | A |
| Construction | 16.3 | E | 16.3 | E | 10.6 | E | 0.8 | A | 0 | A | 0 | A | 0 | A |
| Manufacturing | 44.9 | A | 38.6 | A | 19.8 | A | 17 | A | 20.4 | A | 13.6 | A | 17.5 | A |
| Food | 38.3 | B | 35.5 | B | 18.4 | B | 30.8 | B | 20.2 | B | 16.3 | B | 13.1 | A |
| Beverage and tobacco product | 38.8 | B | 33.9 | B | 17.3 | B | 44.8 | B | 21.8 | B | 25.2 | B | 9.5 | B |
| Textile mills | 45 | B | 31.3 | B | 17.4 | B | 12.2 | B | 5.2 | A | 8.8 | A | 20.7 | B |
| Textile product mills | 33.3 | B | 27.2 | B | 18.1 | B | 25.3 | B | 21.2 | B | 11 | B | 20.1 | B |
| Clothing | 24.6 | B | 22.4 | B | 7.5 | B | 21.3 | B | 13.8 | B | 15.3 | B | 15.1 | B |
| Leather and allied product | 33.3 | B | 17 | B | 14 | A | 24.5 | B | 16 | A | 19.6 | B | 11.4 | A |
| Wood product | 41.3 | B | 33.5 | B | 14.8 | B | 14.8 | B | 19.2 | B | 12.5 | B | 21.6 | B |
| Paper | 53.4 | B | 45.6 | B | 20.5 | B | 14.1 | B | 9.8 | A | 9.5 | A | 9.4 | A |
| Printing and related support activities | 49.2 | B | 49.2 | B | 29.9 | B | 7.4 | B | 26.2 | B | 16.4 | B | 22.5 | B |
| Petroleum and coal product | 46.2 | B | 42.5 | B | 19.2 | B | 11.5 | B | 15.3 | B | 3.8 | A | 3.8 | A |
| Chemical manufacturing except pharmaceutical | 39.9 | B | 47.1 | B | 15.8 | B | 13.8 | A | 16.8 | B | 12.9 | A | 17.7 | B |
| Pharmaceutical | 60.5 | B | 52.6 | B | 23.4 | B | 25.8 | B | 29.9 | B | 19.4 | B | 20.6 | B |
| Plastics and rubber products | 52.4 | B | 46.3 | B | 22 | B | 16.7 | B | 24.1 | B | 14.4 | B | 18.6 | B |
| Motor vehicle plastic parts | 58.4 | B | 52.1 | B | 20.4 | B | 19.7 | B | 10.5 | B | 14.1 | B | 14.1 | B |
| Non-metallic mineral product | 41.9 | B | 43.7 | B | 17.2 | B | 12.4 | B | 22.8 | B | 15 | B | 18.3 | B |
| Primary metal | 38.6 | B | 37.9 | B | 24.9 | B | 6.8 | A | 16.3 | A | 5.9 | A | 17.8 | A |
| Fabricated metal product | 45.3 | B | 37.9 | B | 21.4 | B | 11.9 | A | 15.6 | B | 8.9 | A | 14.9 | B |
| Machinery | 47 | B | 37.1 | B | 19.2 | B | 12.6 | B | 16 | B | 12.5 | B | 19.1 | B |
| Computer and electronic product | 61.8 | B | 42.2 | B | 24.3 | B | 24.9 | B | 34.1 | B | 19 | B | 21.8 | B |
| Electrical equipment, appliance and component | 55.5 | B | 39.4 | B | 22.6 | B | 24.6 | B | 24.2 | B | 18.2 | A | 22 | B |
| Transportation equipment | 48.9 | A | 40.4 | A | 19.8 | A | 18.6 | A | 21.2 | A | 11.1 | A | 16.2 | A |
| Motor vehicle | 61.1 | B | 50 | B | 16.7 | B | 11.1 | B | 38.9 | B | 33.3 | B | 16.7 | B |
| Motor vehicle body and trailer | 47.8 | B | 31.3 | B | 11.3 | B | 19.5 | B | 26.3 | B | 10.9 | B | 20.9 | B |
| Motor vehicle parts | 45 | B | 41.1 | B | 23.3 | B | 25 | B | 18.7 | B | 10.8 | B | 13 | B |
| Aerospace product and parts | 70.6 | B | 62.7 | B | 32.7 | B | 4.6 | A | 17.9 | B | 6.2 | A | 19.5 | B |
| Furniture and related product | 37.3 | B | 29 | B | 11.7 | B | 14.8 | B | 25.1 | B | 15 | B | 17.5 | B |
| Miscellaneous | 49.9 | B | 45.8 | B | 30.4 | B | 16.3 | B | 27 | B | 18.4 | B | 20.9 | B |
| All surveyed industries except manufacturing | 18.6 | B | 24.8 | B | 13.9 | A | 10 | A | 24.7 | B | 14.1 | B | 15.4 | B |
| Wholesale Trade | 34 | E | 32.4 | E | 10.9 | B | 25.2 | E | 33.2 | E | 8 | B | 24.2 | E |
| Retail Trade | 0 | A | 15.7 | E | 0 | A | 2.5 | A | F | 15.7 | E | 14.9 | E | |
| Transportation and warehousing | 23.7 | B | 29.3 | B | 19.7 | B | 7.3 | A | 16.3 | B | 6.7 | A | 18.8 | B |
| Information and cultural industries | 32 | B | 44.6 | B | 19.1 | B | 17 | B | 31.4 | B | 19.2 | B | 23.2 | B |
| Finance and insurance | 29.1 | B | 40.2 | B | 26.2 | B | 11.3 | B | 28.4 | B | 13.4 | B | 11.5 | B |
| Real estate and rental and leasing | 0 | A | 0 | A | 0 | A | 0 | A | 1.7 | E | 1.7 | E | 0 | A |
| Professional, scientific, and technical services except scientific research and development services | 39.5 | B | 51.6 | B | 25.2 | B | 15.6 | B | 31.2 | B | 18.2 | B | 23.2 | B |
| Scientific research and development services | 45.7 | B | 50.3 | B | 24.9 | B | 21.8 | B | 23.9 | B | 10.3 | B | 7.2 | B |
| Management of companies and enterprises | 0 | A | 0 | A | 0 | A | 0 | A | 0 | A | 0 | A | 0 | A |
| Administrative and support, waste management and remediation services | F | F | F | 8.9 | E | F | 38.3 | E | F | |||||
| By firm size | Organizational innovation | Marketing innovation | |||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Business practices for organizing procedures | Methods of organizing work responsibilities procedures | Methods of organizing external relations | Aesthetic design or packaging | Methods or techniques for promotion | Methods for product placement | Methods of pricing | |||||||||
| % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | % | QI | ||
| All industries | Large Enterprises | F | F | F | 16.0 | E | F | 19.0 | E | F | |||||
| Medium Enterprises | 34.2 | E | 40.8 | E | 25.0 | E | 17.1 | B | 30.2 | E | 16.4 | B | 22.4 | E | |
| Small Enterprises | 20.4 | A | 23.8 | B | 12.4 | A | 10.1 | A | 23.0 | B | 13.3 | B | 14.3 | B | |
| Manufacturing | Large Enterprises | 59.0 | A | 49.9 | A | 28.9 | A | 25.2 | A | 25.3 | A | 15.2 | A | 18.4 | A |
| Medium Enterprises | 52.3 | A | 41.1 | A | 22.1 | A | 18.1 | A | 21.9 | A | 14.2 | A | 18.7 | A | |
| Small Enterprises | 42.1 | A | 36.9 | A | 18.4 | A | 15.9 | A | 19.6 | A | 13.3 | A | 17.2 | A | |
| All Except Manufacturing | Large Enterprises | F | F | F | F | F | F | F | |||||||
| Medium Enterprises | 29.3 | E | 40.7 | E | 25.8 | E | 16.8 | E | 32.4 | E | 17.0 | E | 23.4 | E | |
| Small Enterprises | 15.7 | B | 21.0 | B | 11.2 | A | 8.9 | A | 23.8 | B | 13.2 | B | 13.7 | B | |